Someone recommend me something that you think will scare me...a link to the movie would be well appreciated too.
I know no fear.
Sounds like you need to watch something old school devoid of any CGI. If you appreciate horror movies, its all about setting the atmosphere, turn off all of the lights and allow yourself to be scared. Sounds like shock horror won't get to you, I recommend the following:
1) Let The Right One In (Original)
2)Nightmare on Elm St. (Original)
5)The Exorcist (Original)
I have a particular respect for the Body Distortion Horror flicks as well, I'm sure there are countless lists of classics floating around. I think you can find most of the forementioned movies in the Netflix instant queue.