Where does your strong opinion on this come from? It sounds like you've been dealing with some very untrustworthy authors/franchises in the past, and that -- IMO -- is making you see NRS's decision, which may be innocent and well-intentioned, in a very negative light.
That's perfectly fine. As long as this is just your opinion vs. my opinion, then there is no right or wrong, and that has been my position all along. The way select screens worked in MK9 was not right or wrong, and the way select screens work (differently) in MKX is not right or wrong, both simply are and we have to make our peace with it.
Exactly, there is no wrong or right. I just feel uncomfortable with these non canon things that I consider unnecessary.
I'm completely ok with those who like to play with a survivor Liu Kang, and I also think that people deserve to have the fun they want to have.
But, for me, since I'm a story guy, I found this survivor appearance BS.
[...]
Well, this opinion came from the game itself.
When I saw Liu Kang, Kung Lao and Kitana alive, I was ok, because we knew some would be revived.
But you finish the game and you know this is not what happened. So, I question myself, why?
And one of your statements mirror a little bit what NRS could have thought.
Would Kitana, Kung Lao and Liu Kang fans like their primary characters the way they really are - revenants?
Let's pick up Sub-Zero. He is alive on the screen, but he was at the least revived. Everybody on the screen is depicted on the late 25's, but those three go beyond reasonable .
NRS was defensive, I don't think - thought I have any konfirmation of this, but it's what I feel - they felt secure to put them on their original forms, as they weren't secure enough to put them as, maybe DLC. At the least Kitana and Liu Kang (let's say Kung Lao does come back with Kung Jin's help).
Now, let's question their inclusion. I like that they are in. But on the story, they were as important as Sindel and Baraka. It's obvious that they were included because of fans (whether it's good or not, that's another subject). But I think they could have been included as playable respecting canon, and not a bad "what if" excuses.
There is no what if. They never made it. At the least put them as revenants, so they could work on their evil beings, new villains.
It's like on "MK11" we got old Liu Kang again and until "MK12" he's still ruler of the Netherrealm. Makes no sense.
In the end, Cassie has beaten Shinnok, not Scorpion, who is on the cover. That's the real cover. Liu kang alive, but he is not alive. You just discover that at the very ending.
I can't see other way that it's not marketing.