RDR vs GTA IV

[SSCREM]

I prefer RDR, bought it a few days ago and to me it's miles better than GTA couldn't even get into that one.

 

[THE JOHNNY ROOK]

The problem with RDR is that you could not just get in a car...

 

[Shirayuki Mizore]

RDR Multiplayer is better.

GTAIV single player is better.

So it's pretty much a tie even though I spent MUCH more time playing GTAIV.

 

[THE JOHNNY ROOK]

I loved RDR but I could never find a car to steal.

 

[Shirayuki Mizore]

I loved RDR but I could never find a car to steal.

I tried to steal that armored car that Edgar Ross had, lol.

 

[THE JOHNNY ROOK]

I was riding this donkey once, and I could not figure out how to change the radio station. GTAIV>RDR

 

[SSCREM]

Johnny could you please be useful and give good feedback somewhere else? Others deserve to witness your divine blessing.

 

[THE JOHNNY ROOK]

I liked in GTAIV when you first encountered a mountain lion.

 

[nemesiswontdie]

I hate everything about RDR. So GTA all the way.

 

[THE JOHNNY ROOK]

I hate everything about RDR. So GTA all the way.

Reported to mods.25

 

[B13-Helghast]

of all GTA's nr 4 was the worst imo, and RDR is a totally diff experience...not comparable except they're both from RS and are free roamers.

 

[Aldo Moreno]

Both are great games!

 

[Treadmill]

Rdr had one of the best stories in gaming history.

Sent from my HTC PH39100 using Tapatalk 2

 

[Shang 'T' Sung]

Actually I thought GUN had a better shorter but better story. We totally need more western games

 

[SSCREM]

+ John > Niko

I'll take a badass american outlaw over a half assed russian any day.

 

[Shirayuki Mizore]

Niko isn't even Russian...

 

[SSCREM]

You get the point, but I'll fix it only for you.

A half assed east European person.

 

[Shirayuki Mizore]

He's Serbian, dude.

And an excellent character. I liked him more than John because I really wanted him to get his revenge more than I wanted John to get his family back.

 

[SSCREM]

Different people have different tastes.

 

[THE JOHNNY ROOK]

Both were hands down amazing, unforgettable experiences. I will never forget the GTAIV ending, made you actually feel that this is America from a foreigners viewpoint. RDR had a great sense of accomplishment and expansion. Both Rockstar titles were top of their class in respective rights.