RDR vs GTA IV

[Jade]

Both games are amazing, but I gotta give this one to Red Dead Redemption. Different atmosphere and really loved the story. Plus, James was a piece of ass.

 

[THE JOHNNY ROOK]

This should have been a polled debate. I absolutely loved GTAIV but RDR's atmosphere and life wins me over. Absolutely loved the western setting. John was a bad ass, through and through.

 

[Jade]

I added a poll.


It was kinda bothering me that it didn't have one, lol.

 

[THE JOHNNY ROOK]

I think I am going to start playing Undead Nightmare. Never played it before and just bought it.

 

[Jade]

It's fun <3

RE meets RDR.

CAN'T GO WRONG

 

[YautjaSanta]

I voted for GTA IV because I loved Episodes from Liberty City.

 

[Shirayuki Mizore]

I think I am going to start playing Undead Nightmare. Never played it before and just bought it.

Put on expert targeting. Normal or casual makes Undead Nightmare WAY too easy.

 

[pgd42]

RDR for me. I never really got into gta4's story like it did with Read Dead and the exploration was so much more fun cause there were actually interesting things to find, especially with undead nightmare (Bigfoot). I think the gritty city atmosphere was the turn off with gta cause the fifth one really looks awesome so far in san andreas.

 

[SSCREM]

The gun fights in RDR are soooo much more satisfying than GTA 4 just the sound and feel of your winchester firing blows you away.

 

[Shirayuki Mizore]

The gun fights in RDR are soooo much more satisfying than GTA 4 just the sound and feel of your winchester firing blows you away.

Henry > Winchester