SOME people on SOME sites said they want Baraka in the game, and SOME people on SOME sites admitted to being only casual fans of the franchise, therefore only fake MK fans want Baraka in MKX/MK11, and real fans want the series to move forward.
Did I get the gist of your argument about right?
No, you didn't get the gist right.
The top comment on most MKX articles on general gaming sites consists of LOTS of people on said sites admitted to being casual fans of the franchise and all of those same people in the same complaint usually follow that casual comment up with "I wanted ________ in the game (referring to Baraka, Cyrax, Smoke, Noob Saibot or Kabal), and would pick MKX up if _________ (again referring to Baraka, Cyrax, Smoke, Noob Saibot or Kabal) was in the game."
Then, you also have that followed by 300 - 400 upvotes of people who also are casuals and comment that they wanted Baraka, Cyrax, Smoke, Noob Saibot or Kabal in the game.
I hate to break it to you, but the truth is that the majority of people who pick up MK games aren't the hardcore fans like me, you and the others on here, TYM, MKO, Kamidogu or any other MK related site.
No.
The majority of the MK "fans" are casuals who would drop MK if their favorite isn't in, hence why dead Kung Lao, Kitana and Liu Kang who otherwise had no importance in the story are in; to appease those people who otherwise wouldn't pick it up.
It's the very reason why the entire Original 7 are in, why Sub-Zero is human and why Mileena, Reptile and Ermac are in.
Did you ever notice how the characters that made the roster are more popular than Styker, Sindel, Sheeva, Shang Tsung and Jade?
Casuals could care less if Styker, Sindel, Sheeva, Shang Tsung and Jade are dead, but they'll be the first to complain, raise a shit-storm and "Wah" the minute that the characters that are more popular than those (like Baraka, Cyrax, Smoke, Noob Saibot or Kabal) are missing from the game.