If this was released around the time Hawkgirl movie was released, would Hawkgirl win? Batman is arguably the most popular DC character at any given time, if number of movies, tv-shows, video games etc. is any sort of indication. Superman might be THE hero, but he's got way less time on spotlight. There is a reason for that whether you pick "He's so OP boy scout it's boring" or "His enemies include Lex, Doomsday, Brainiac... and... and"
I'm happy with the results because anything else would mean that trolls and funnymen and people who apply comic logic (meaning tier levels would be all over the place) had their way of giving protest votes or whatever. Now that would mean this is a pointless poll. If Hawkgirl and Cyborg faced each other in the finals...