Yeah, and I think ultimately that's where we differ. I get that you like Bi-Han because hes colder, but thats the exact reason I dont and feel that is why his character is much more befitting of Noob Saibot.
Ultimately if what you guys say is true and the soulnado separates bi-Han from noob saibot (I still say they're the same character) then that would remove all evil from Bi-Han because the soulnado would purify him basically. So would he he not be essentially Kuai Liang except the older brother this time? I mean what im saying is the cold personality would be gone. Hell kuai liang was "cold" himself in the old timeline only helping the good guys when raiden would ask. He kept himself secluded in the Lin kuei temple besides that. I guess im just saying this cold character you want would be gone. Because the sub-zero that would emerge would be good.
Plus in Kuai's defense, he didnt magically stop being Sub-zero just because hes cyber and died. Just like kitana didnt stop being kitana and kung Lao didnt stop being kung Lao.
Personally I think it would be interesting if smoke inhabited the cyber body but could leave at free will. That would give us both smoke, and cyber smoke. If not then let sektor reprogram cyber subs body and have sub-zero face him once sareena helps resurrect him.
The cold Sub-Zero you guys are wanting though is dead. If Bi-Han emerges from the soulnado he should be purified of evil and that should make him want to fight for good. If you want evil badass Bi-Han though look no further than Noob Saibot.
I didn't say I wanted evil Bi-Han, I just liked him more before because he didn't give a crap in MK9, and was more in it for himself, the same way that Scorpion (in the latter games) was neutral.
If the Soulnado separates Bi-Han from Noob Saibot, and cleanses him, he would probably become humble and join the good guys, but at the same time it's also developing his character.
People always complain that Sub-Zero was a boring character after MK4, and him being humbles by the experience and being more in the mentor role, would be befitting, considering that it's a more maturing experience.
I never said that Kuai stopped being Sub-Zero, EVER.
Hell, I don't see why he can't come back too.
Ideally I'd like to see all 3 in MK10 (Bi-Han, Noob Saibot and CSZ).
I just gave a good explanation as to how Bi-Han could come back as Sub-Zero.
THAT'S ALL.
Smoke doesn't need to be turned again.
Smoke got saved in MK9, and they should explore the "demon" version of him in his MK9 ending, IMO.
That would be a much better development for his character, and make him his OWN character, rather than being connected to Noob Saibot again.
Again, the cold Sub-Zero that I have loved would just be humbled and made into a better person,from the Soulnado experience, and Bi-Han could actually be a neutral character, rather than being tied down to Noob Saibot or the NetherRealm.
Noob or Saibot (whichever name is more associated with the wraith), should have his own story aside from Bi-Han, after he is separated from Bi-Han with his OWN motives for wanting to rue the NetherRealm.
The wraith that was infused with Bi-Han, may have just been another "run-of-the -mill" demon, and now that he has the opportunity to seize control of the NetherRealm, and he can take that shot.
Bi-Han, being humbled by the experience can convince Scorpion, that they were both screwed over by Quan Chi, and form an allegiance with Scorpion to take down a common enemy, and "bury the hatchet" between them.
It would let Scorpion and Bi-Han's characters both evolve, so that their story isn't stale.