if fighting styles were hidden

rocky

BANALITY
scenario: lets say that your opponent chooses Sub zero (A) and you always choose scorpion (B) against Sub zero (A) for whatever reason. But your scorpion (B) is not so good against their sub zero (B). but your Kotal Kahn is a good match for both their sub zero (A) and (B) but not as good as your scorpion (B) when it comes to fighting sub zero (A)

Now imagine that all you know is that your opponent has chosen sub zero but you dont know what version (A) (B) or (C)
so now you have to think should i choose my scorpion (B) just incase they have chosen Sub zero (A) but its a risk because they might of chosen Sub zero (B) and remember your scorp (B) vs Subz (B) is not so good, so then you think well maybe i should choose kotal Kahn since hes good against both subz (A) and (B) but only just.

see what im saying if you didnt know what fighting style your opponent chose you would have to think more about the match up possibilities rather than always playing safe and choosing the same version against a particular version

i think if done this way the whole various fighting styles thing would of had more point to it.

i would of preferred it if each character had only one costume for all fighting styles. for example scorpion would always have the swords on his back but only uses them if you pick that particular fighting style that enables swords.

they could of had it so that the other player can only see what character you have selected but cant see what fighting style you have chosen nor would i put their fighting style on the top screen next to their name. so when the match starts the other player wont know what to expect.

the fact that the alt costumes gives away what fighting style you have chose seems to defeat the purpose imo, it would be better if it was kept hidden. i know the idea that theyre going for is that you can chose different versions coz maybe version A of a character is a better match up against version B of the the other character but isnt that like going right back to square one? where people will most Likely always pick Version A against to fight against version B.

im probably the only one that would prefer the fighting styles hidden but im interested in what people think
 
they should make hidden cursor like mk9, so no counter picking in the beginning. then it depends on tournament's rule (variation lock or not). i just don't really care much cuz i have to deal with bad MUs everytime i play FG.
 
I think there should be a hidden cursor option like in Mk9. I think wanting to remove the costume variations and the name in the corner seems overkill and pointless. I'm sure less than 30 seconds in the other person will know what variant you have and having your style hidden doesn't matter once everyone's characters are locked in.
 
It would be nice if at least in ranked matches, you never saw who they were picking until you have selected your character and get locked-in. I hate the constant counter-picking bullshit in MK9. People always waiting for me to pick first. If I go hidden and select, they do the same thing. Which is 100% pointless if I've already selected who I want to play as. Too much time is wasted with people in Player Select.
 
The whole point of the variations was to prevent counter picking and bad match ups, I thought? MK9 hidden cursor was fine.
 
. People always waiting for me to pick first. If I go hidden and select, they do the same thing. Which is 100% pointless if I've already selected who I want to play as. Too much time is wasted with people in Player Select.

Urrgh, I can't stand that s#%t!!!!!

Hidden variation select is a MUST.
 
This is my idea. Ok we know they can possibly do something to allow the opposing player online not be able to see which one you pick, but the real problem would be playing against someone next to you. To solve that issue i think they should allow us to use 3 buttons to select a variation, square for V1, triangle for V2, X for v3, and of course circle would be cancel. Welp that all i got lol.
 
^That would actually be pretty sick. Like selecting a play in Madden.



In the Machina interview though, Lawrence brought this up to Ed Boon. Who then said that they had not even thought of that. And that if it turned out to be a problem down the road then they'd consider a hidden select. So it seems like they wont have that option at launch, unless we voice our concerns.


@2:40 he asks

 
Wow that's terrible. I hope they do this in an update if it doesn't happen before the game comes out. This post probably would need to be on the official site.
 
Top