Well...I've discussed RE5 and its faults a lot, though not here I don't think. As a solid action game I give it a 9.0. It was very fun, had lots of replayability, fun achievements/trophies, a good collector's edition...but it was no Resident Evil game. Where RE4 departed from the series it still retained an atmosphere of tension, isolation, anxiety, and a feeling that you could be overwhelmed at any time.
But in RE5 the atmosphere takes a back seat, you never feel like the characters believe they are in any danger, ammo is never a concern, puzzles are non-existent, and every aspect of the game draws you out of it...like anti-immersion.
But let's talk gameplay issues. RE5 alters the formula, and makes it an action game. Moving and shooting a la Dead Space feels almost necessary, yet it's not there. The inventory system makes no sense, is extremely limiting, and requires constant attention. Not to mention the AI...oh god the AI...I'm not even going to get into the AI, it would take hours.
Well, that's gameplay and atmosphere out of the way; how about plot/storyline? Can anybody say "atrocious dissapointment"? Because I can. Wesker, my FAVORITE character in Resident Evil...was ruined. He was made awesome and badass with his matrix moves. And I loved that. But he intrigue, his mystery, his grand plan that has been spanning the ENTIRE FECKING SERIES...turns out to nothing more than a TYPICAL megalomaniacal plot straight out of a comic book...from the 30s. Wesker stays behind the scenes in EVERY game, ceaselessly collecting samples of every virus or contagion that's ever caused anybody grief...he hires Hunk and Ada to do his work for him and keep his involvement secret. He hoodwinks the protagonists into giving him exactly what he needs. And WHAT does he do with it? HE SELLS IT. TO FUND A PLAN NOBODY HAS EVER HEARD OF. And yet, we've all heard it a million times before. It RUINS him for me. My favorite character. Ruined...
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ok, bad stuff out of the way. It's a great game. If I don't think about it too hard it turns out to be enjoyable, great to play with friends, the costumes are HOT (tribal Sheva and jumpsuit Jill FOR THE WIN), and collecting everything kept me entertained for weeks. And I got EVERYTHING. 1000/1000 gamerscore (only the second game I've done that for), every action figure, every difficulty, all S ranks (on at least 1 difficulty), I even mucked about in Professional difficulty with that IDIOT partner. I like RE5 as a game. But as anything more, anything I want to look into on a deeper level (as I like to do), it is deeply disappointing.