ChiefThunder said:
undertaker3x7 said:
I just saw it. I thought it was badass, very well done especially the look and the sound of it. It followed the games well enough and I thought it was a very good story.
Well that's enough for me, dude.
You and Goro have helped me to breathe a little easier by both of you making very positive comments. I was so worried that SH would suck ass :lol:
Then allow me, cheif, to take a piss all over your hopes and dreams lol. I'm a huge SH fan myself, at one time the proud owner of a save file on my memory card that included a save before every boss in the game, and one before the rebirth/devil boss for every ending on the game, before topping it off nicely with a save in the lighthouse before the UFO ending. I even had the Hyper Blaster.
When it started, with the first few bars of
that music, I actually raised my power-ballad fist in the air in triumph. And the beginning, aside from sean bean's horrible accent, looked very promising. It all did, until they met the cult, and it went to pot from there. If you don't want spoilers don't read this.
WRONG THINGS (aside from the obvious harry not being female);
Dahlia is not a good character
Dahlia didn't love alessa, she forced her into evil acts
The siren wasn't physical, it was just a noise that sounded when 'The Darkness' came
Cybill DOESN'T DIE!
Dahlia DOES DIE!
Too many people. Silent Hill is supposed to be deserted, only summoning people to it when the need arises. Nobody actually lives there.
Pyramid Head was a product of James Sunderlands imagination, therefore shouldn't have been there.
If all of Dahlias relatives hated her and Alessa, then Claudia wouldn't have been in Silent Hill 3
Silent Hill isn't limbo. If you have to be dead to enter that realm, how come Harry lived through it?
The list goes on.
It seems to me that somebody wrote a horror movie, realised it just wasn't good enough to stand on it's own, so changed a few things and called it Silent Hill to give it hype. It isn't a
bad film, but it isn't Silent Hill.
But if a few of the names were changed and a few other things, it could have made a pretty good prequel to the first game. But it didn't. And the ending was AWFUL.