Storing Fatality Inputs

I've been through and done all the fatalities, babalities, etc, on every character and the game nicely stores the inputs, but only for controller one (player one). So if I play with friends offline and end up playing from the right side of the screen (ie. controller 2) none of the fatalities are stored, why? It's a bit tedious to have to do them all twice on the same system and I can't work out why that is the case.

The fatalities you have are only unlocked on your profile.

So you should like write down or print out all the fatalities for player 2.

Yeah I learnt that yesterday, I started to do the inputs with controller 2 and realised they weren't being stored, that's just annoying, I wish they hadn't done that.