What is the perfect review?
There is no such thing as a perfect review, as they are inherently subjective. What you get out of a movie may not be the same as another reviewer depending on personal taste. However, some reviews are articulated better than others. I like to think of a review as a critique. You try to inform the audience the the merits of the film and things that could have been improved upon.
~What do you guys hope for when you search for reviews?
I like reviews to be concisely written, and thoughts well-organized. Humor is a plus, but it shouldn't be forced as timing is important if you want to use it.
~Do you like reviews that give number scores (8/10)?
Or maybe grades would be better(B+)?
I personally feel scores/grades are not necessary. They do not measure anything objective and it seems like people make too much of a fuss about them than necessary. Going outside of movies for a bit, so many people here were making a big stink when MK9 reviews got scores less than a 9/10...it's as if they are using these scores to confirm their own biases. I prefer to let the writing speak for itself.
That being said, if you insist on having it, a numerical score from a scale of of 1-10 are more flexible than letters.
~Do you prefer one score or many scores that are tallied up into one finale score?
As stated previously, you don't really need it, but if you want to take that route...
Having several scores in categories such as script, acting, cinematography, or anything you feel that makes an important aspects of the movie, followed by an overall score. Don't bog it down with too many categories though.
~What don't you like about movie reviews?
I find a lot of reviewers are incoherent and tend to go into a rant about about something they don't like.
~What do you think most reviews are lacking?
Most reviews do not offer suggestions to the author/creators that will help them improve their work in the future.