Calactyte you just HAD to have something crumbly didn't you? You toned down the crumblyness on the obelisk but then added crumblyness to the barrier next to it which isn't in the original either. Seriously.. look at the original.. there are cracks on the bridge (albeit not as deep as the ones you made) but none of the side parts are crumbly. It's like you moved it from one spot from your previous render to the other. Also the cracks wouldn't be perfectly symmetrical on both sides of the arena like that. The damage should be different in different spots. At the very least you should remove or change the damage on one side of the arena.
Other than that it looks very good.
Calactyte you just HAD to have something crumbly didn't you? You toned down the crumblyness on the obelisk but then added crumblyness to the barrier next to it which isn't in the original either. Seriously.. look at the original.. there are cracks on the bridge (albeit not as deep as the ones you made) but none of the side parts are crumbly. It's like you moved it from one spot from your previous render to the other. Also the cracks wouldn't be perfectly symmetrical on both sides of the arena like that. The damage should be different in different spots. At the very least you should remove or change the damage on one side of the arena.
Other than that it looks very good.
I agree 100%I do think that we should take advantage of HD and not be afraid to add some detail not present in the original without going overboard.
Even for an HD version there's still a little too much crumbling going on and again the cracks are symmetrical in an unnatural way... symmetry means it looks exactly the same on both sides. You just don't coincidently get the same exact kind of cracking like that evenly on both sides of someplace like that.
Yes, it's an HD version but things should still make sense and look good and I don't think having the corners completely chipped away like that looks the best. The corners are looking more ill defined than broken to me.
He did a real good job with the obelisk pillar and it looks a lot better now than it did before when he had the same kind of crumbling going on there...
If he was to keep the crack on the bridge that's fine I guess but again he should modify the other side to be less symmetrical. If he doesn't want to that's fine too since it is all up to him after all.
BTW, I went to college for design.
Also I doubt he's going to take my suggestions anyway.
I agree 100%
Pit is looking sweet. make sure you put the moon inside the 720 visible pixels. it stay in the same place always